“The Herdmans were absolutely the worst kids in the history of the world. They lied and stole and smoked cigars (even the girls) and talked dirty and hit little kids and cussed their teachers and took the name of the Lord in vain and set fire to Fred Shoemaker’s old broken-down toolhouse.”
What’s the Story?
Imogene, Ralph, Claude, Leroy, Ollie, and Gladys Herdman are infamous for their wild behavior—smoking, swearing, drinking, shoplifting, and even arson. With an absent father and an overworked mother, they’ve avoided discipline and are passed through school to avoid multiple siblings in the same class.
When they attend Sunday school for the first time (they heard there were free snacks), they shock everyone by volunteering for all the lead roles in the Christmas pageant. With no alternatives—the Herdmans bully the regular cast into silence—Beth’s mother casts them: Imogene as Mary, Ralph as Joseph, Claude, Ollie, and Leroy as the Wise Men, and Gladys as the Angel of the Lord.
Fearing the Herdmans, local mothers refuse to let their babies play Jesus, so a doll is used instead.
Unfamiliar with the nativity story, the Herdmans take it seriously, prompting Beth and her parents to reflect on its harsher realities—like Mary giving birth in a barn and Herod’s plot to kill Jesus.
Though the town expects disaster, the Herdmans’ raw, unpredictable performance makes the pageant unexpectedly powerful: Imogene cradles the doll tenderly, the Wise Men bring a ham, and Gladys delivers her lines with fierce conviction. Beth is stunned to see Imogene quietly crying during the final scene. Everyone agrees—it’s the best pageant the town has ever seen.
Why is it Great?
Barbara Robinson’s The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is a short, funny, and surprisingly heartfelt holiday classic that has remained a favorite for decades—and for good reason. On the surface, it’s a lighthearted story about a small-town Christmas pageant hijacked by the Herdmans, six wild, misbehaved kids no one expects to care about anything, let alone a Bible story. But beneath the humor lies a deeper message about compassion, grace, and the unexpected ways people can change.
What makes the book great is its ability to be both hilarious and moving. The Herdmans are outrageous—setting things on fire, stealing, and strong-arming their way into starring roles in the pageant—but they also approach the nativity story with raw sincerity, having never heard it before. Their confusion and emotional reactions challenge the townspeople—and the reader—to reconsider the familiar tale through fresh, unfiltered eyes.
Robinson’s writing is sharp and accessible, with just enough edge to keep it from being overly sentimental. She captures both the chaos of the pageant and the quiet beauty of its transformation into something real and meaningful.
Ultimately, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is great because it reminds us that the Christmas story isn’t just for a select few but, rather, it’s for everyone.
This article contains affiliate links.